Islamabad: The Federal Constitutional Court (FCC) declared infrastructure development cess imposed by Sindh and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa unconstitutional, ruling that provinces cannot exercise legislative powers reserved exclusively for Parliament.
In a detailed 59 page judgement reported on Saturday, the court held that the federal government's failure to exercise a particular taxation power does not automatically transfer that authority to provincial governments.
A two member bench comprising Chief Justice Aminuddin Khan and Justice Aamer Farooq issued the ruling on 568 challenges filed by taxpayers against the infrastructure levies.
Court overturns previous high court rulings
The FCC accepted the taxpayers' appeals and overturned earlier judgements of the Sindh High Court and Peshawar High Court, which upheld the provincial charges.
The court declared the relevant charging provisions, along with associated rules, notifications, assessments and recovery measures, unconstitutional and without lawful authority.
It also ruled that demands, surcharges and penalties based solely on the invalid charges could no longer be enforced.
Securities submitted exclusively against the disputed levies must be discharged after verification, subject to any existing judicial orders governing their release.
Federal authority over imports and exports
The dispute concerned whether infrastructure charges imposed by provincial governments were legitimate fees for using provincial facilities or taxes on activities falling within federal jurisdiction.
Sindh imposed its levy under the Sindh Development and Maintenance of Infrastructure Cess Act, 2017, while Khyber Pakhtunkhwa introduced a similar charge through its Infrastructure Development Cess Act, 2022.
The KP legislation was subsequently amended through the Finance Act, 2024.
The taxpayers argued that the charges effectively regulated imports, exports and interprovincial trade, matters constitutionally reserved for the federal legislature.
The provincial governments defended the levies, saying they supported road construction, transport infrastructure and services used by commercial operators.
The FCC ruled that the stated purpose of infrastructure development could not, on its own, establish the provinces' authority to impose charges on federally regulated trade.
Provincial autonomy remains constitutionally protected
The court explained that the 18th Constitutional Amendment expanded provincial legislative authority by abolishing the Concurrent Legislative List.
However, it did not transfer subjects expressly reserved for the federation.
The judgement also clarified that provinces receiving a share of federal revenue under the National Finance Commission arrangements do not acquire the authority to impose those federal taxes themselves.
The court said provinces could still introduce constitutionally valid infrastructure or service charges on goods manufactured and consumed within their territories.
The ruling therefore invalidates the disputed charges while preserving the provinces' authority to legislate and raise revenue within their constitutional jurisdiction.





