Lahore: The Lahore High Court on Thursday asked its registrar’s office to explain why an application seeking enforcement of its orders to curb smog in Punjab had been listed before a two judge bench.
The bench, headed by Justice Ahmad Nadeem Arshad, heard arguments from advocate Azhar Siddique, who said the departments responsible for carrying out the court’s directions had failed to do so. He asked for the application to be placed before a single judge, noting that the orders at issue had been issued by a single-judge bench.
Siddique said former Lahore High Court judge Shahid Karim had heard the smog case for eight years and issued directions to government departments to control air pollution. He alleged that the departments had set those directions aside after Karim retired and that smog had worsened as a result. His application asks the court to enforce those orders rather than issue a new set of directions.
The case now raises two questions: which bench should hear the application, and whether the departments have complied with the earlier orders. Thursday’s direction concerned the first. It called for an explanation from the court’s own registrar’s office, not a report from government departments on what they had done to curb smog.
The bench did not transfer the application to a single judge or make a finding on the alleged failure to comply. The account of the hearing did not specify when the registrar’s report was due or include a response from the departments named in the application.





